Side-by-side · honest numbers
Amex Membership Rewards CC vs American Express SmartEarn Credit Card vs IDFC Ashva Gold (FD)
Honest side-by-side comparison of Amex Membership Rewards CC, American Express SmartEarn Credit Card, IDFC Ashva Gold (FD) — annual fees, reward rates, income eligibility, and estimated net annual value on the same spend profile.
At a glance (moderate spend)
Quick verdict: On moderate spend, American Express SmartEarn Credit Card ranks first for estimated net annual value — ahead of IDFC Ashva Gold (FD) by about ₹50/yr.
| Feature | Amex Membership Rewards CC American Express | American Express SmartEarn Credit Card American Express | IDFC Ashva Gold (FD) IDFC FIRST Bank |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fees & eligibility | |||
| Annual fee | ₹4,500 | ₹495 | Lifetime free |
| Fee waiver threshold | No waiver published | Waived at ₹40,000/yr spend | Lifetime free |
| Min income | ₹60,000/mo | ₹25,000/mo | Not stated |
| Secured / FD-backed | Standard | Standard | FD-backed |
| Rewards | |||
| Net annual value (moderate) | ₹822/yr | ₹1,650/yr | ₹1,600/yr |
| Online shopping | — | 5 pts per ₹25 spend → ₹25/mo (₹300/yr) (cap hit) | — |
| Top reward rate | 2 RP/₹150 | 10X Membership Rewards | 2X reward points |
| Primary reward cap | No monthly cap published | ₹500 eligible spend/mo | No monthly cap published |
| Perks & restrictions | |||
| Lounge access | None | None | Domestic lounge with FD ≥ ₹25K · FD-backed card — lounge tied to minimum ₹25,000 fixed deposit, not monthly spend |
| UPI rewards | Not supported (Visa/MC) | Not supported (Visa/MC) | Not supported (Visa/MC) |
| Key exclusions | EMI · Fuel · Rent · Some small merchants | Fuel · Insurance · Utilities · EMI · Rent | Not stated |
| Bonuses | |||
| Signup bonus | ₹4,000 | — | — |
Frequently asked questions
- Which card has the lower annual fee?
- IDFC Ashva Gold (FD) has a ₹0 annual fee (lifetime free or zero-fee tier).
- Which card earns more on moderate spend?
- American Express SmartEarn Credit Card leads with an estimated ₹1,650/yr net annual value on moderate spend.
- Which card has the lower income requirement?
- American Express SmartEarn Credit Card lists a minimum monthly income of ₹25,000.
- Which cards are secured (FD-backed)?
- IDFC Ashva Gold (FD) is secured — useful for thin credit files without a bureau pull at application.
- Does this comparison pull my credit score?
- No. CardHungry estimates net value from public fee and reward rules only — no bureau check.
Customize your spend
Change spend profile or swap cards — results update live below.
Amex Membership Rewards CC
American Express
American Express SmartEarn Credit Card
American Express
IDFC Ashva Gold (FD)
IDFC FIRST Bank
Your adjusted comparison
| Feature | American ExpressPlatinum Amex Membership Rewards CC •••• •••• •••• 4242 Quick facts Amex Membership Rewards CC Top reward2 RP/₹150 Annual fee₹4,500 Min income₹60,000/mo Tap to flip back Amex Membership Rewards CC American Express | American ExpressGold American Express SmartEarn Credit Card •••• •••• •••• 4242 Quick facts American Express SmartEarn Credit Card Top reward10X Membership Rewards Annual fee₹495 Min income₹25,000/mo Tap to flip back American Express SmartEarn Credit Card American Express | IDFC FIRST BankGold IDFC Ashva Gold (FD) •••• •••• •••• 4242 Quick facts IDFC Ashva Gold (FD) Top reward2X reward points Annual feeLifetime Free Tap to flip back IDFC Ashva Gold (FD) IDFC FIRST Bank |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fees & eligibility | |||
| Annual fee | ₹4,500 | ₹495 | Lifetime free |
| Fee waiver threshold | No waiver published | Waived at ₹40,000/yr spend | Lifetime free |
| Min income | ₹60,000/mo | ₹25,000/mo | Not stated |
| Secured / FD-backed | Standard | Standard | FD-backed |
| Rewards | |||
| Net annual value (moderate) | ₹822/yr | ₹1,650/yr | ₹1,600/yr |
| Online shopping | — | 5 pts per ₹25 spend → ₹25/mo (₹300/yr) (cap hit) | — |
| Top reward rate | 2 RP/₹150 | 10X Membership Rewards | 2X reward points |
| Primary reward cap | No monthly cap published | ₹500 eligible spend/mo | No monthly cap published |
| Perks & restrictions | |||
| Lounge access | None | None | Domestic lounge with FD ≥ ₹25K · FD-backed card — lounge tied to minimum ₹25,000 fixed deposit, not monthly spend |
| UPI rewards | Not supported (Visa/MC) | Not supported (Visa/MC) | Not supported (Visa/MC) |
| Key exclusions | EMI · Fuel · Rent · Some small merchants | Fuel · Insurance · Utilities · EMI · Rent | Not stated |
| Bonuses | |||
| Signup bonus | ₹4,000 | — | — |
Share this comparison
https://cardhungry.com/in/en/compare/amex-mrcc-vs-amex-smartearn-vs-idfc-ashva-goldMore Amex Membership Rewards CC comparisons
- Amex Membership Rewards CC vs 811 Dream Different Credit Card
- Amex Membership Rewards CC vs AU Altura Credit Card
- Amex Membership Rewards CC vs AU Zenith Credit Card
- Amex Membership Rewards CC vs American Express Gold Card
- Amex Membership Rewards CC vs American Express Platinum Travel Card
- Amex Membership Rewards CC vs Axis Bank ACE Credit Card
- Amex Membership Rewards CC vs Axis Bank Airtel Credit Card
- Amex Membership Rewards CC vs Axis Bank Atlas Credit Card
- Amex Membership Rewards CC vs Axis Bank Flipkart Credit Card
- Amex Membership Rewards CC vs Axis Bank Magnus Credit Card
- Amex Membership Rewards CC vs Axis Bank My Zone Credit Card
- Amex Membership Rewards CC vs Axis Bank Neo Credit Card