Side-by-side · honest numbers
Amex Membership Rewards CC vs American Express SmartEarn Credit Card vs SBI Card against Fixed Deposit
Honest side-by-side comparison of Amex Membership Rewards CC, American Express SmartEarn Credit Card, SBI Card against Fixed Deposit — annual fees, reward rates, income eligibility, and estimated net annual value on the same spend profile.
At a glance (moderate spend)
Quick verdict: On moderate spend, SBI Card against Fixed Deposit ranks first for estimated net annual value — ahead of American Express SmartEarn Credit Card by about ₹120/yr.
| Feature | Amex Membership Rewards CC American Express | American Express SmartEarn Credit Card American Express | SBI Card against Fixed Deposit SBI Card |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fees & eligibility | |||
| Annual fee | ₹4,500 | ₹495 | Lifetime free |
| Fee waiver threshold | No waiver published | Waived at ₹40,000/yr spend | Lifetime free |
| Min income | ₹60,000/mo | ₹25,000/mo | Not stated |
| Secured / FD-backed | Standard | Standard | FD-backed |
| Rewards | |||
| Net annual value (moderate) | ₹822/yr | ₹1,650/yr | ₹1,770/yr |
| Online shopping | — | 5 pts per ₹25 spend → ₹25/mo (₹300/yr) (cap hit) | — |
| Top reward rate | 2 RP/₹150 | 10X Membership Rewards | 80% of FD value |
| Primary reward cap | No monthly cap published | ₹500 eligible spend/mo | No monthly cap published |
| UPI rewards | Not supported (Visa/MC) | Not supported (Visa/MC) | Not supported (Visa/MC) |
| Key exclusions | EMI · Fuel · Rent · Some small merchants | Fuel · Insurance · Utilities · EMI · Rent | Not stated |
| Bonuses | |||
| Signup bonus | ₹4,000 | — | — |
Frequently asked questions
- Which card has the lower annual fee?
- SBI Card against Fixed Deposit has a ₹0 annual fee (lifetime free or zero-fee tier).
- Which card earns more on moderate spend?
- SBI Card against Fixed Deposit leads with an estimated ₹1,770/yr net annual value on moderate spend.
- Which card has the lower income requirement?
- American Express SmartEarn Credit Card lists a minimum monthly income of ₹25,000.
- Which cards are secured (FD-backed)?
- SBI Card against Fixed Deposit is secured — useful for thin credit files without a bureau pull at application.
- Does this comparison pull my credit score?
- No. CardHungry estimates net value from public fee and reward rules only — no bureau check.
Customize your spend
Change spend profile or swap cards — results update live below.
Amex Membership Rewards CC
American Express
American Express SmartEarn Credit Card
American Express
SBI Card against Fixed Deposit
SBI Card
Your adjusted comparison
| Feature | American ExpressPlatinum Amex Membership Rewards CC •••• •••• •••• 4242 Quick facts Amex Membership Rewards CC Top reward2 RP/₹150 Annual fee₹4,500 Min income₹60,000/mo Tap to flip back Amex Membership Rewards CC American Express | American ExpressGold American Express SmartEarn Credit Card •••• •••• •••• 4242 Quick facts American Express SmartEarn Credit Card Top reward10X Membership Rewards Annual fee₹495 Min income₹25,000/mo Tap to flip back American Express SmartEarn Credit Card American Express | SBI CardClassic SBI Card against Fixed Deposit •••• •••• •••• 4242 Quick facts SBI Card against Fixed Deposit Top reward80% of FD value Annual feeLifetime Free Tap to flip back SBI Card against Fixed Deposit SBI Card |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fees & eligibility | |||
| Annual fee | ₹4,500 | ₹495 | Lifetime free |
| Fee waiver threshold | No waiver published | Waived at ₹40,000/yr spend | Lifetime free |
| Min income | ₹60,000/mo | ₹25,000/mo | Not stated |
| Secured / FD-backed | Standard | Standard | FD-backed |
| Rewards | |||
| Net annual value (moderate) | ₹822/yr | ₹1,650/yr | ₹1,770/yr |
| Online shopping | — | 5 pts per ₹25 spend → ₹25/mo (₹300/yr) (cap hit) | — |
| Top reward rate | 2 RP/₹150 | 10X Membership Rewards | 80% of FD value |
| Primary reward cap | No monthly cap published | ₹500 eligible spend/mo | No monthly cap published |
| UPI rewards | Not supported (Visa/MC) | Not supported (Visa/MC) | Not supported (Visa/MC) |
| Key exclusions | EMI · Fuel · Rent · Some small merchants | Fuel · Insurance · Utilities · EMI · Rent | Not stated |
| Bonuses | |||
| Signup bonus | ₹4,000 | — | — |
Share this comparison
https://cardhungry.com/in/en/compare/amex-mrcc-vs-amex-smartearn-vs-sbi-fd-securedMore Amex Membership Rewards CC comparisons
- Amex Membership Rewards CC vs 811 Dream Different Credit Card
- Amex Membership Rewards CC vs AU Altura Credit Card
- Amex Membership Rewards CC vs AU Zenith Credit Card
- Amex Membership Rewards CC vs American Express Gold Card
- Amex Membership Rewards CC vs American Express Platinum Travel Card
- Amex Membership Rewards CC vs Axis Bank ACE Credit Card
- Amex Membership Rewards CC vs Axis Bank Airtel Credit Card
- Amex Membership Rewards CC vs Axis Bank Atlas Credit Card
- Amex Membership Rewards CC vs Axis Bank Flipkart Credit Card
- Amex Membership Rewards CC vs Axis Bank Magnus Credit Card
- Amex Membership Rewards CC vs Axis Bank My Zone Credit Card
- Amex Membership Rewards CC vs Axis Bank Neo Credit Card